After fundraising, the east end of St Peter’s is substantially re-ordered to fit the needs of modern worship. The medieval chancel screen is moved back from the west tower arch to the east arch, its openings closed up, the figures of saints and angels are moved up and the whole screen is painted in bold colours and gold leaf. It becomes the reredos of a new Sanctuary area underneath the crossing beneath the tower, with a white marble paved floor. The old chancel area, now screened off, becomes a vestry. The huge mural over the tower arch is badly deteriorated, and is painted over. The choir stalls are moved from the old chancel to the St John’s Chantry, along with the organ. The total cost of the restoration and re-ordering is about £24,000 (£480,000 in today’s money). On 5th November 1960, the new high altar is consecrated by the Bishop of St Albans.
